Is Bathtub Refinishing Worth It?

If your tub is stained, dull, or rough to the touch, it’s easy to assume the only “real” solution is replacement. But in most Chicago bathrooms, replacing a bathtub isn’t a simple swap — it often turns into tile damage, plumbing adjustments, days of disruption, and a bill that climbs fast.

Bathtub refinishing is usually worth it when the tub itself is structurally solid (especially cast iron or steel) and the problem is the surface — worn enamel, discoloration, scratches, chips, or rust spots. Done professionally, refinishing can make an old tub look new again without demolition.

What refinishing actually does (and what it doesn’t)

A new tub isn’t the expensive part — the work around it is.

Replacing a bathtub commonly involves:

• removing or damaging tile to get the tub out,

• plumbing work (drain, overflow, valves),

• disposal, delivery, and hauling,

• repairs to walls/floor after removal,

• multiple trades and multiple days.

If your bathroom is not being remodeled anyway, refinishing is often the smarter move.

Typical cost in Chicago: refinishing vs replacement

Spraying is widely used because it’s quick to apply and can look good at first.

How long does refinishing last?

With professional prep + quality materials + proper care, refinishing can last many years, and in many cases up to 10–15 years. We also back our work with a warranty (details depend on the project type).

Longevity comes down to two things:

1. Preparation (cleaning, sanding, bonding)

2. Material + method (not all “refinishing” is the same)

ADVANTAGES OF FINISH YOUR BATHTUB

When bathtub refinishing is NOT worth it

Here are the situations where we’ll usually recommend a different solution:

• The tub moves or flexes

  If the tub floor feels spongy or you hear cracking sounds under load, that’s typically a support/installation issue (common with low-quality acrylic/fiberglass). A new surface won’t fix movement.

• Structural cracks or active leaks

  If water is escaping through the tub body or there are deep cracks that keep spreading, replacement may be the safer option.

• You’re already doing a full remodel

  If tile, layout, plumbing fixtures, and the tub are all being replaced anyway, refinishing may not make sense.

• Severe corrosion or metal failure

  Some steel tubs rust from the underside or develop serious weak spots. If the metal is failing, the surface can’t compensate.

What types of tubs are best for refinishing?

Cast Iron Tubs

Heavy, stable, and built to last. When the surface wears out, refinishing is a great way to keep the tub for years.

Steel Tubs

Also refinishable when the structure is solid. Rust spots and chips can usually be repaired during prep.

Acrylic / Fiberglass Tubs

Possible in some cases — but only when the tub is stable and properly supported. The biggest enemy is flexing.

What to expect during the process

Most projects follow a simple flow:

We keep the process as low-disruption as possible for occupied apartments.

How to care for a refinished tub (so it lasts)

To protect the finish:

• Use non-abrasive cleaners (no gritty powders)

• Remove or mask hardware as needed

• Don’t leave bottles/soap sitting in puddles for days

• Use a soft mat only if it’s approved for refinished surfaces (ask us)

Simple care makes a big difference in lifespan.